Key ingredients
4.2/5
Semi Sweet is the shade on Milani's Stay Put waterproof pencil, and the pencil includes a sharpener and a smudger.
Home/ Brands/ Milani/ Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet
Tap to enlarge
Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet
$9.97
Semi Sweet is the shade on Milani's Stay Put waterproof pencil, and the pencil includes a sharpener and a smudger. The page says the formula is sweat-resistant and that you twist clockwise to bring the product up. The smudger is there when you want the brown line blurred, which a felt pen cannot do on its own. Twist slowly, because a long click wastes a soft pencil on the first sharpen.
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
The Edyt Score
4.4 / 5.0
Targets
4.1/5
This brown eyeliner is a semi Sweet.
Formula standards
4.4/5
The formula is a semi Sweet.
The verdict
Semi Sweet is the shade on Milani's Stay Put waterproof pencil, and the pencil includes a sharpener and a smudger.
Compare against similar products
Side-by-side vs 6 near substitutes (REVLON, NYX, MAYBELLINE, e.l.f., COVERGIRL, and L'Oreal Paris). Compare best for, format, finish, Edyt score, and notes. Swipe sideways to compare.
| Pick | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Semi Sweet pencil with a smudger | Waterproof brown pencil, shade 203 | Matte brown liquid liner | Mechanical pencil in Espresso | Coffee shade in a waterproof pen | Slim espresso pencil, 0.008 oz | Mechanical brown, up to 16 hours |
| Format | Pencil | Pencil | Liquid pen | Mechanical pencil | Felt pen | Pencil | Mechanical pencil |
| Finish | Semi Sweet | Brown | Matte brown | Espresso | Coffee | Espresso | Brown |
| Edyt score Methodology: The Edyt Score reflects ingredient profiles, concentration, and formulation standards. It is separate from crowd-sourced user reviews. | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.3 | 4.4 |
| Notes | Smudger | 203 · 0.01 oz | Liquid · Brown | Mechanical | 0.06 oz · Pen | 0.008 oz | 0.008 oz · 16 hours |
| $ / size | $9.97 | $7.61 | $10.77 | $7.98 | $4.00 | $5.97 | $9.97 |
| Shop | Buy on AmazonThis page | Buy on AmazonProduct page | Buy on AmazonProduct page | Buy on AmazonProduct page | Buy on AmazonProduct page | Buy on AmazonProduct page | Buy on AmazonProduct page |
FAQ
Who is Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet best for?
Semi Sweet is the shade on Milani's Stay Put waterproof pencil, and the pencil includes a sharpener and a smudger. The page says the formula is sweat-resistant and that you twist clockwise to bring the product up. The smudger is there when you want the brown line blurred, which a felt pen cannot do on its own. Twist slowly, because a long click wastes a soft pencil on the first sharpen.
How did Edyt Beauty score this brown eyeliner?
Edyt Beauty rates Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet 4.4 out of 5 from the ingredient list, who it is for, and how the formula is built. That is separate from crowd-sourced user reviews.
How does it compare to similar products?
The compare table above stacks Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet against near substitutes for the same shopping job, including picks from REVLON, NYX, MAYBELLINE, e.l.f., COVERGIRL, and L'Oreal Paris. For more from the same brand, see More from Milani below.
Where can I buy it?
Shop Stay Put waterproof eyeliner Semi Sweet with the Buy button when it is available. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability can change. You can also find it in our guide to Best Brown Eyeliners.
You may also like
REVLON
ColorStay eyeliner pencil 203 Brown
$7.61
NYX
Epic Wear liquid eyeliner Brown
$10.77
MAYBELLINE
Unstoppable mechanical brown eyeliner Espresso
$7.98
e.l.f.
waterproof eyeliner pen Coffee
$4.00
COVERGIRL
Perfect Point Plus eyeliner Espresso
$5.97
L'Oreal Paris
L'Oreal Infallible Never Fail eyeliner pencil Brown
$9.97