Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap

Q: How did Edyt Beauty score this product?

Edyt Beauty rates Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap 4.9 out of 5 based on formula fit — ingredient profile, who it is built for, and formulation quality — not star averages or paid placement.

Edyt rating4.9

Methodology: The Edyt Score reflects ingredient profiles, concentration, and formulation standards. It is separate from crowd-sourced user reviews.

$13.99

Ideal choice for dry, sensitive skin needing gentle, nourishing cleansing, if you aren't vegan.

Buy on Amazon Back to Pretty farm girl

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

The Edyt Score

4.9 / 5.0

Key ingredients 4.8/5

A fragrance-free buttermilk tallow and goat-milk bar made for sensitive skin. The quietest single bar in this set, not honey and not salt.

Targets 4.9/5

For dry, reactive skin that wants the mildest unscented cleanse. Skip the honey unscented bars if buttermilk is the base you want.

Formula standards 4.9/5

A soft, fatty bar with no perfume, and it still is animal fat, so it is not vegan. Dry it between showers.

The verdict

The sensitive-skin bar to keep if fragrance is off the table. One bar.

Compare against similar products

Side-by-side vs 5 near substitutes (Pyunkang Yul, Dove, Cetaphil, Carolina Castile Soap, and Good Molecules) — best for, key actives, texture, skin fit, Edyt score, and notes. Swipe sideways to compare.

Pretty farm girl Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap compared with similar products
Pick	This product Pretty farm girl Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap	Alt 1 Pyunkang Yul Ultimate Calming Solution Cream	Alt 2 Dove Beauty Bar Soap Sensitive, 8 Bars for Sen…	Alt 3 Cetaphil Gentle Cleansing Bar Soap, Sensitive & Dr…	Alt 4 Carolina Castile Soap Gin & Juniper Castile Bar Soap	Alt 6 Good Molecules Clarify and Cleanse Bar, Salicylic Acid B…
Best for	Buttermilk unscented tallow bar	Sensitive skin	Bar soap	Bar soap	Sensitive skin: it gently cleanses	Bar soap
Key actives	Tallow	Shea butter	—	—	—	Salicylic acid
Texture	Formula	Cream	Formula	Formula	Formula	Formula
Skin fit	Sensitive	Sensitive	Sensitive	Sensitive	Sensitive	—
Edyt score Methodology: The Edyt Score reflects ingredient profiles, concentration, and formulation standards. It is separate from crowd-sourced user reviews.	4.9	4.7	4.2	4.2	4.8	4.2
Notes	Fragrance-free · -skin fit	Anti-acne · Anti-redness	Fragrance-free · -skin fit	-skin fit	-skin fit	-
$ / size	—	$24.35	$12.97	$9.99	—	$5.00
Shop	This page	Buy on Amazon Product page	Buy on Amazon Product page	Buy on Amazon Product page	Buy on Amazon Product page	Buy on Amazon Product page

FAQ

Who is Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap best for?

Ideal choice for dry, sensitive skin needing gentle, nourishing cleansing, if you aren't vegan.

How did Edyt Beauty score this product?

Edyt rates Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap 4.9 out of 5 based on formula fit — ingredient profile, who it is built for, and formulation quality — not star averages or paid placement.

How does it compare to similar products?

The compare table above stacks Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Tallow Soap against near substitutes for the same shopping job, including picks from Pyunkang Yul, Dove, Cetaphil, Carolina Castile Soap, Mrs. MEYER'S, and Good Molecules. For more from the same brand, see More from Pretty farm girl below.

Where can I buy it?

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability can change. You can also find it ranked in our guide to hypoallergenic bar soaps for calm, soothed skin.