Home/ Guides/ best pink eyeliners

8 Best Pink Eyeliners Worth Trying

Published 10/08/2026

Pink eyeliner splits in a way you notice the second it's on. A soft, muted pink can sit along the lash line and nearly vanish on a fair lid, reading more like flush than liner. A brighter one holds its color in daylight and people see it. Then there's the tool: a wood pencil smudges into something soft and a liquid pen leaves a line with an edge, and those two choices change the whole thing.

Our top picks

Swipe →

Compare the best

Side-by-side tradeoffs for this shortlist, best for, format, finish, Edyt score, and notes. Same picks; swipe sideways to compare.

8 Best Pink Eyeliners Worth Trying, compared side by side
Pick
Best forA matte pink liquid penA sharpenable punchy pink pencilA pink creme pencilA muted pink for the lower lash lineA dual-ended pink gel pencilA twist-up pink pencilA pale pink gel penA bold pink wing
FormatLiquid penSharpenable pencilCreme pencilRetractable gel pencilDual pencilTwist pencilGel penAuto pencil
FinishMatte pinkPunchy pinkPinkMuted pinkMatte and metallicPinkPink champagneBright matte
Edyt score

Methodology: The Edyt Score reflects a comprehensive analysis of ingredient profiles, concentration levels, and formulation standards. It is an objective technical evaluation of the product's composition, separate from crowd-sourced user reviews.

4.54.54.34.44.44.24.44.3
NotesSneaky pinkPencilShock TherapyMild Pink · Gel pencilDual ended · 0.04 ozTwist upCalabasasHot pink · Waterproof
$ / size$4.20$5.95$4.49$11.99$15.00$5.99$8.00$9.99
ShopBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead reviewBuy on AmazonRead review

Our picks, explained

Best matte pink liquid

NYX Vivid Brights Liquid Liner, Sneaky Pink

Vivid Brights liquid liner in Sneaky Pink, matte tip.

Sneaky Pink is a Vivid Brights liquid liner. NYX calls the finish matte and the formula smear-resistant, with a precise tip for a thin line or a wing. Liquid pink sets darker than it looks on the felt, so the first stroke should be the thin one. A felt tip frays once the pen is used on a dry lid every day, and a soft pink line can vanish on a fair lid unless you build a second pass along the lash line.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade is Sneaky Pink, in a liquid pen.
  • Vivid Brights liquid liner in Sneaky Pink, matte tip.

What to keep in mind

  • A felt tip frays with daily use on a dry lid.
  • A soft pink line can disappear on a very fair lid.

Best sharpenable pink pencil

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Eyeliner, Punchy Pink

Tattoo Studio pencil in Punchy Pink, waterproof, 36-hour claim.

Punchy Pink is a Tattoo Studio pencil you sharpen. Maybelline says the gel pigments are waterproof and smudge resistant and rates them for 36 hours with no fading. A wood pencil gives you a fresh point after each sharpen, which is how a bright pink stays a line and not a smudge. The 36-hour line is a long claim for a cream pencil on an oily lid. Sharpening also shortens the pencil, so a bright pink you use every day runs out faster than a twist stick.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade is Punchy Pink, and the pencil is sharpenable.
  • It is waterproof and rated for 36 hours of wear.

What to keep in mind

  • Sharpening uses up a bright pencil faster than a twist stick.
  • A 36-hour claim is optimistic on an oily lid.

Best pink creme pencil

wet n wild On Edge Eyeliner, Shock Therapy

On Edge creme pencil in Shock Therapy, pink, up to 12 hours.

Shock Therapy is the pink shade of the On Edge pencil. wet n wild calls it a creme liner that is smudge-proof and fade resistant, with wear up to 12 hours. Creme pink blends if you want a soft wash along the lash line, and it also moves if you touch it before it sets. Twelve hours is a shorter claim than the 36-hour pencils on this page. The price is the low one in the group, which fits a pink you might wear once and put back in the drawer.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade name is Shock Therapy, a pink creme pencil.
  • It is smudge-proof, with wear up to 12 hours.

What to keep in mind

  • Creme pink moves if you touch it before it sets.
  • Twelve hours is a shorter claim than the 36-hour pencils.

Best soft pink gel pencil

Heart Percent Dote On Mood Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Mild Pink

A muted pink for the lower lash line

Heart Percent's Dote On Mood pencil in Mild Pink is a muted pink with a soft nude undertone, made for the aegyo sal look under the eyes as much as for lining. The gel texture glides and blends at first, then sets waterproof and resists smudging. It is far softer than a hot pink liner, so it suits anyone who wants pink that reads as a glow rather than a statement. The pencil twists up, so there is no sharpener, but the tip cannot be sharpened back to a fine point either.

Why it makes the list

  • A muted pink that doubles as an under-eye highlight.
  • Waterproof gel formula that sets and resists smudging.

What to keep in mind

  • Too soft for a bold graphic pink line.
  • A retractable tip cannot be sharpened to a fine point.

Best dual-ended pink gel

Morphe Bi-Liner, Yours or Mine

Bi-Liner in Yours or Mine, matte and metallic, 0.04 oz.

Yours or Mine is a dual-ended gel pencil at 0.04 oz. Morphe says one end is matte pink and the other is metallic, with transfer, water, and smudge resistance. Two tips in one pencil is the reason it is on a pink-liner page. The second bullet also calls the pencil dark, so the metallic end may read deeper than the matte end once it is on the lid. At 0.04 oz the pencil is small, and a dual tip means each side holds less product than a full-size single pencil.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade is Yours or Mine, with a matte end and a metallic end.
  • The pencil is 0.04 oz and resists water and smudging.

What to keep in mind

  • Each end holds less than a full single pencil.
  • The metallic end can look darker than the matte end.

Best twist-up pink pencil

DekRion Pink Eyeliner Pencil

Pink eyeliner pencil, waterproof on the title, twist-up tip.

DekRion's title calls this a pink waterproof eyeliner pencil. The pencil has a flexible tip and a twist-up, retractable design. Waterproof on the title means a remover at night. A no-name pink can be sheerer than Punchy Pink once it is on the lid, so swatch the tip before you commit to a wing.

Why it makes the list

What to keep in mind

  • A no-name pink can look sheerer on the lid than the swatch.

Best pink gel pen

ColourPop BFF Gel Liner, Calabasas

BFF crème gel liner in Calabasas, 0.01 oz, 18-hour claim.

Calabasas is a BFF crème gel liner, a waterproof pen at 0.01 oz. ColourPop lists 18 hours of wear and calls the formula high pigment. The same shade name shows up in the brand's two-pen set as pink champagne, a pale pink with a metallic cast, so it sits quieter than a hot pink pencil. The barrel is short. A gel tip stays wet for a moment, and a blink before it sets prints the color onto the lid.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade is Calabasas, in a 0.01 oz waterproof pen.
  • ColourPop rates it for 18 hours of wear.

What to keep in mind

  • The pen is small, so a daily wing uses it up.
  • A wet gel line transfers if you blink before it sets.

Best hot pink liquid

Metfdlaig Waterproof Hot Pink Liquid Eyeliner

A bold pink wing

A waterproof hot pink liquid liner with an ultra-fine, flexible tip for sharp cat eyes. The color is intense and long wearing, and the formula resists smudging. It is hypoallergenic, so it suits sensitive eyes.

Why it makes the list

  • The shade is Baby Pink, GP376, in an auto pencil.
  • The formula is a smudge-proof gel.

What to keep in mind

  • A pale pink line can vanish on a deeper lid.

How we made this list

We chose 8 picks for pink eyeliners. Each one is ranked on how well it suits the need, its Edyt Score from our editorial breakdown, and brand variety, so one company does not fill the list.

  1. Define the need. Pink eyeliner splits in a way you notice the second it's on.
  2. Vary the brands. We keep one product per brand unless a second one does something clearly different.
  3. Score the formula. Rankings use Edyt’s editorial breakdown (ingredients, target fit, finish, and use case).
  4. Cut near-clones. When two products did the same thing, we kept the one with the higher score or the clearer use.

FAQ

Who is pink eyeliner for?

People who want one pink liner, in a pen, a pencil, or a dual-ended gel.

How did Edyt Beauty score these picks?

We checked pigment load, film-forming agents for lasting wear, and whether each formula lists emollients or waxes that help the liner glide without tugging. Liquid, gel, and pencil formats were compared for opacity and ease of creating a clean line. The order follows the Edyt Score, so the top picks combine strong color payoff with comfortable application.

How do the top picks compare?

NYX Vivid Brights Sneaky Pink is a matte liquid pen. Maybelline Tattoo Studio Punchy Pink is a sharpenable waterproof pencil with a 36-hour claim. wet n wild Shock Therapy is a pink creme pencil with an up-to-12-hour claim. Heart Percent Mild Pink is a muted gel pencil that sets waterproof. Morphe Bi-Liner Yours or Mine is a dual-ended pink gel at 0.04 oz. DekRion is a pink pencil with a twist-up tip. ColourPop BFF in Calabasas is a waterproof gel pen at 0.01 oz with an 18-hour claim. L.A. Girl Pastel Dream Baby Pink, shade GP376, is an auto pencil with a smudge-proof gel formula.

Where should I buy them?

Use the Buy buttons on this page when a product is in stock. Prices and availability can change. Check the product page before you buy.

Should I pick pink eyeliner, blue, brown, or a gel formula?

Pink liner works when you want a soft flush along the lash line, especially a muted pencil that smudges into the skin and reads like warmth on the eye. A blue eyeliner makes a louder statement and holds its color in daylight, so it suits days you want people to notice. Brown eyeliner stays quiet and defines the lashes for everyday wear. Gel eyeliner comes in a pot or chunky pencil and gives you a dense, long-wearing line you can shape with a brush before it sets.

This is general beauty guidance, not medical advice. Patch-test new products if you have sensitive skin or known allergies.

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission from links on this page. Prices and availability change.